data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a9299/a929974b32cf664e2ec2f04eb77c9a8920aa7495" alt=""
Happy Columbus Day! When I was a kid that actually meant something. Columbus was cool, not the villain he has been betrayed as in recent years. Christopher Columbus discovered America and was a great explorer. But now his reputation isn't so stellar and teachers are making sure students know about his "dark side".
A recent article about the upcoming Columbus Day school celebrations talked about what some teachers are doing to give their classes a more "fair" picture of the great explorer:
Jeffrey Kolowith's kindergarten students read a poem about Christopher Columbus, take a journey to the New World on three paper ships and place the explorer's picture on a timeline through history. "I also talk about the situation where he didn't even realize where he was," Kolowith said. "And we talked about how he was very, very mean, very bossy."
In McDonald, Pa., 30 miles southwest of Pittsburgh, fourth-grade students at Fort Cherry Elementary put Columbus on trial this year — charging him with misrepresenting the Spanish crown and thievery. They found him guilty and sentenced him to life in prison."In their own verbiage, he was a bad guy," teacher Laurie Crawford said.Sweet. So Columbus is bad and we are making sure our kids know. That really comes as no surprise since our Founding Fathers had their faults and have been labeled in harsh terms because of some of their beliefs and practices. As a historian, I find this new curriculum of judging people, such as Columbus, by our standards completely asinine. It makes no sense at all because these historical figures were products of the society in which they lived, not ours. Slavery was acceptable, native populations were seen as barbaric, and everyone was out to discover land. That was the way most of Europe thought at Columbus' time.
Some argue that Columbus didn't really discover America because he thought he had hit the West Indies instead. Well, duh. He didn't know there was a bug mass of land blocking his way and so thought he had reached his destination. Maps back then were a joke, being highly inaccurate. They did believe in sea monsters after all and that the world was flat. They didn't have all the technology that we do today so cut the man some slack.
Others argue that the natives were the first ones there and so they really discovered America. True, they were the first to inhabit the land, but Columbus is the one who came across them. Furthermore, the European world had no idea America was there, let alone the people, so that would make Columbus the first one to discover that this land and people did exist. And, to be honest and not politically correct, the side that has the more power and education is usually the one that gets the credit for discoveries.
People also say Columbus is wicked for bringing disease and death to the natives. Well, idiot, do you really think he knew about germs and what he was doing by bringing two worlds together? Have you any idea of the medical knowledge in that time period? Not the best. It's unfair to blame Columbus for introducing those germs into those indigenous societies because he didn't even know they existed. The only way we know that is through hindsight. Thanks to modern medicine we know about germs and how disease spreads and we can look back and see how native populations were affected by European diseases. But don't say Columbus came knowingly carrying plague and death with him. That's just stupid.
When it comes down to it, those who hold historical figures like Columbus up to our modern standards are hypocrites and no better then those they profess superiority to. If Columbus was bad for judging the natives by his European standards, are we not even worse off because we impose the same sentences on him based on our modern philosophies. We have the advantage of time and, therefore, an increase of knowledge. We know about disease, the shape and land in the world, and that all men are equal. Are we not just as pompous and imperialistic when we look down our noses at Columbus and call him wicked because he does not meet our standards?
Yeah for Columbus and his discovery of America. He forever changed history. He helped bring in an era of discovery and exploration that has made us who we are today. For that I am grateful and see him as hero.